Clock struck 2 and it means it was our chance to get lucky for the second time .
Yes you got it Right !! time for our another class with Mandi Sir .
Let's see what magic he has in his bag this time .
He took out some blocks and asked two very simple questions to us :-
Question 1 : How many blocks will any of us be able to keep one over the other ?
Our response : 17 , 18 , 20 ...14..22, 25 many response came in .
Question 1 : How many blocks will any of us be able to keep one over the other , when blind folded .
He'll be not alone and will be guided by one of our another fellow mate who will not be blindfolded .
Our response : number suddenly dropped ..and came down to 8 , 10 , 12 .....
every one sighted the reason that being blindfolded and guided by someone else would be difficult and hence less blocks can be put in .
sir nodded with a smile on his face and asked us to come forward and perform both the scenario .
So here goes the action :
One of our batch mate volunteered and he managed to put in 22 blocks .
Now it was the turn of blind folded person to do the same exercise and he was to be guided by another person .
And he managed to put in......hmmm..
any guesses ...
...
...
...
...
....
well it is 25 .
We all were awestruck and amazed to see the result of this exercise .
The reasoning behind this task was to bring forth the differences between new management and old management .
Here , the first instance resembles the way old management works and the blindfolded instance can be equated to new management and some important difference between them can be listed down as below : -
Difference 1 : Type of work
Old management resembles the way craftsman use to work , where few of the person do the work completely .
Example : Shoe maker , he makes the shoes completely by himself .
or a tailor who stitches the complete shirt by himself .
In New management , work is divided into segments or different units , where each unit handles specific kind of work .
Example : So if same shirt to be made in factory equipped with new management , then each part of it viz color , pocket , sleeves , front side , back side will be stitched in different units and assembled into one in final stage .
Conclusion : The process is ambiguous and not very clear in old management .
In contrast to this new management defines every process lucidly and clearly . Thus complete process becomes easy and faster .
Difference 2 : Decision making
In old management ,decision making lies completely in the hand of worker .
the success and failures of the task is dependent completely on him .
as in the apropos experiment , in first case the person was solely responsible for all the blocks that he'll put .
This will put pressure on him as he is responsible for all the perils .
While in new management all the decision making lies with leadership . Thus worker is to act as if blindfolded and only follow instruction .
Conclusion : Process becomes more crystal clear as the decision making lies completely in the ambit of leadership . At the same time role of worker becomes limited and he is to only follow instruction and not think on his own about decision making .
This can be one ill effect as worker may get irked because of monotonous job . This has to be handled carefully by HR department .
Difference 3 : Skill set
In old management the skill set is more ,since all the task are performed by the worker himself .
This gets highlighted in the example of tailor as he is the one who makes all the units of shirts and finally stitches them together .
While in new management , skill set decreases for the very obvious reason that each worker always works on one particular unit only .
Conclusion : In new management system skill set of worker decreases .
It fact here Management aims at
deskilling worker . Thus idea is to make things more process oriented rather then resource oriented . This reduces the dependency on resources and amplifies the role of management as it gives them more control and it is easier to get hold of processes when compared to resource .
Difference 4 : Satisfaction level
Since there are less controls and decision making abilities in the hand of worker , satisfaction levels are low in new management system as compared to old management system .
Conclusion : HR has a very important and critical role to play in new management system because of low satisfaction level . Thus HR department has to make sure that employee does not get frustrated because of this .
Thus Mandi sir was yet again successful in oiling our brains with some great and new learning combined with fun .
It was a two hour class only, but it managed to teach some serious happenings of management world and the way new age companies work .